Re: [rti_india] Fw: RTI Landmark Judgment Regarding 2nd appeal

kindly attach file in attachments

On Thu, Aug 12, 2010 at 5:55 PM, Subrata Kundu <subratakundu111@yahoo.co.in> wrote:

[Attachment(s) from Subrata Kundu included below]

----- Forwarded Message ----
From: Subrata Kundu <subratakundu111@gmail.com>
To: Abdul <irrwsngo@gmail.com>; Abhijit <abhijitsd08@gmail.com>; Abhijit Ghosh <ghoshabhijit123@rediffmail.com>; Aheli <aheli.chowdhury@gmail.com>; AICURD <aicurd@yahoo.com>; AICURD2 <aicme@dataone.in>; Amanat <amanat_kolkata@yahoo.com>; Amitabha <amitabha57@gmail.com>; Amitabha <saamit1@hotmail.com>; Amitabha Sarkar <sarkaramitabha@yahoo.com>; Amitadyuti <Amitadyuti@gmail.com>; Anibrata <anibratapramanik05@gmail.com>; Anirban Banerjee <anirban.ananda.banerjee@gmail.com>; Anshuman <dasanshuman@yahoo.com>; ANUPAM <anupampaul99@gmail.com>; Ardhendu <ardhendu.sc@gmail.com>; Arpita <chaudhuri.arpita@gmail.com>; Arpita <ghosharpita@rediffmail.com>; ASED <asedkol@gmail.com>; ASHA <ashacal@cal3.vsnl.net.in>; Ashish <ashbis@gmail.com>; Ashok <ashokkumarsircar@gmail.com>; Ayesha <khatun.ayesha@gmail.com>; BAPU <bapu.india@gmail.com>; BBDS <bbdsorg@gmail.com>; Bhabesh <bhabeshdas@hotmail.com>; Bharat <bharatmansata@gmail.com>; Biplab <biplab2k06@yahoo.com>; Biswajit <biswajitdas06@gmail.com>; Brahmacharis <brahmacharis@gmail.com>; CASA <casaberham@sify.com>; CDHI <jcdhi@rediffmail.com>; CINI <cini@cinindia.org>; CJKS <cjks.2006@rediffmail.com>; Credibility Alliance RC EAST <rceast@credall.org.in>; CRS <secretary@csraindia.org>; CSRA <csra.org@gmail.com>; D <dpal2020@yahoo.co.in>; Debjeet <debjeet2002@gmail.com>; Deblina <dlina_gupta@yahoo.com>; Dipak <dipakbarapanda@gmail.com>; DISHARI <dishari@vsnl.net>; Diti <ditimo@gmail.com>; DJKS <djks.org@gmail.com>; DRCSC <drcsc@alliancekolkata.com>; DRCSC <drcsc@vsnl.com>; DSRD <dsrdwb@vsnl.net>; Elhmarst <elminstt@gmail.com>; Gargi <gargighosh@wbati.org>; GBS <gbs2@rediffmail.com>; HASUS <hasus00@rediffmail.com>; HCCWS <hccws@rediffmail.com>; HLWS <lifewelfaresociety@gmail.com>; Indrani <bcindrani@gmail.com>; Ishani <ishanibiswas@gmail.com>; Ishani Datta Ray <ishani69@gmail.com>; JABALA <jabala@vsnl.net>; Jamgoria <jamgoria.sevabrata@rediffmail.com>; Jamgoria <jamgoria@gmail.com>; JAR <jabalaactionresearch@yahoo.com>; Jayanta <octave06@rediffmail.com>; Khanpur <kagus_ngo@rediffmail.com>; KJKS <kjks1001@yahoo.com>; Lakhan <lakhanmalda@gmail.com>; Latiful <momin_latiful@rediffmail.com>; LCA <lca@cinindia.org>; LKP <lokakalyanparishad@gmail.com>; LWS <kolkata@lwsi.org>; Malay <bhattacharyyamalay@yahoo.co.in>; Malay <malay234@gmail.com>; Malay <malaydewanji@gmail.com>; Mandralionsclub <somnathsingharoy@gmail.com>; Manik <maniksingha240@gmail.com>; MBBCDS <mbbcds@hotmail.com>; Md Lutful <lutful55@gmail.com>; MINA <nishtha1975@gmail.com>; MKSS <mkssrajasthan@gmail.com>; MSKS <msks_msd@yahoo.co.in>; MSS <mssorg@gmail.com>; MSS2 <rtimalda@gmail.com>; Nabin <nabin24@gmail.com>; Nandini <nandini.ceo.rda@gmail.com>; Nandini <nbasistha@gmail.com>; nandiniAtDrcsc <nandiniatdrcsc@gmail.com>; Nayana <nchowdhury@sdtatatrust.com>; NCPRI <ncpriwb.rti@gmail.com>; Patheya <patheya_msd@yahoo.com>; piyali <piyakundu@gmail.com>; Prayas <prayas2001@gmail.com>; PRIA <info@pria.org>; PRIA <kolkata@pria.org>; Provat <vpbk_org@vsnl.net>; Rabi <rabiroy2009@rediffmail.com>; Rabin <rabin.middey@gmail.com>; RabinM <robinm@vsnl.net>; Raghu <raghuchakraborty@sify.com>; Raj <rajkrishna.mukherjee@gmail.com>; Rajat <royrajat@yahoo.com>; Rajesh <rajeshdattain@yahoo.com>; Ranjit <janasevasociety@yahoo.com>; Ranjit <ranjitmaiti@gmail.com>; Ranjit <rkm-prd@nic.in>; RHDC <rhdc_aus02@rediffmail.com>; RSSO <hukemard@gmail.com>; RTIIndia <admin@rtiindia.org>; RTInerwb <rtinetwb@yahoogroups.com>; Sabir <sabirahamed@gmail.com>; Sailesh <sailesh2@vsnl.com>; Samjog <samjog_news@yahoo.co.in>; Sanchar <sanchar@vsnl.com>; Sankar <sankar_sanyal@yahoo.co.in>; Sankar <sdb_r@yahoo.com>; Saradindu <saradindu@pria.org>; Shankar <sankarchakraborty03@yahoo.co.in>; Shibesh <shibeshdas@gmail.com>; Shikshamitra <shikshamitra@yahoo.co.in>; Shouvik <datta.shouvik@gmail.com>; Sitangsu <sitangsukumar@gmail.com>; SMOKUS <smokusorg@yahoo.com>; Snehasish <surs@vsnl.com>; Sohini <sohini@humanrightsinitiative.org>; Sohini <sohini_paul2004@yahoo.co.in>; Somjita <somjita00.2007@gmail.com>; Sonarekha <c.sonarekha@gmail.com>; Soumen <soumen102@rediffmail.com>; Sourabh <gghosh6@gmail.com>; Sourav Ghosh <souravdrcsc@gmail.com>; Sovon <ruralaid03@rediffmail.com>; SPADE <spadekolkata@gmail.com>; SPAN <info@spanvoice.org>; SPAR <sparcal@vsnl.com>; SPMUS <spmus_ngo@rediffmail.com>; SRDTC <srdtc@dataone.in>; SRDTC <srdtcnbp@gmail.com>; Sristy <sristy2006@rediffmail.com>; SSUP <ssupmalda@gmail.com>; STEP <reja2007@gmail.com>; Subhasish <subhasishb1@gmail.com>; Subrata <subratakunduu@gmail.com>; Sudip Das <sudip18das@yahoo.co.in>; sujit 2 <sujit568@gmail.com>; Sujit Sinha <sujit586@gmail.com>; Sujit Tua <sujit_tua@yahoo.com>; Sukdeb Hazra <sukdebhazra@yahoo.in>; SUKUMAR SINGH <mass@cal.vsnl.net.in>; Sumit Sanyal <sumitkumarsanyal@gmail.com>; Suparna Mitra <suparnamitra06@gmail.com>; Swapan Das <kalu1951@gmail.com>; SWI <raigunj@gmail.com>; Tapas Mondal <tapas.drcsc@gmail.com>; Tapas Mondal <tapastrg@yahoo.co.in>; Tarun Debnath <tarunkumardebnath@gmail.com>; Tarun Samity <samity.tarun@rediffmail.com>; TSRD <tagoresociety1@gmail.com>; TSRD Tapan <tsrd_tapan@rediffmail.com>; Utpal Sen <tapf55@gmail.com>; Vani India <vaniindia@airtelbroadband.in>; Venkatesh Nayak <venkatesh@humanrightsinitiative.org>; WBEN <wben@vsnl.net>; WBIC <scic-wb@nic.in>; WBSHGPF <wbshgpf@yahoo.co.in>; subratakundu111@yahoo.co.in
Sent: Thu, 12 August, 2010 5:52:38 PM
Subject: RTI Landmark Judgment Regarding 2nd appeal

Dear all
The single bench of Justice Jayanta Kumar Biswas of Calcutta High Court, in response to a writ petition filed by a RTI applicant Mr. Akhil Kumar Roy directed West Bengal Information Commission to dispose off the second appeal with in 45 days from the date of the order.

The judgment is very important from the view point of arbitrary time schedule of disposing off the second appeal with in the frame work of RTI Act 2005. The judgment is also important from the view point of reasoning and natural justice and would be of highest of credence to the RTI aspirants of the country. The copy of the judgment is attached herewith.

Regards
Subrata .