Thursday, January 31, 2013

[IAC#RG] Fwd: Hindi SE rashtravaad KA sambandh

Mr Sanjay Chaturvedi /Dr Rina Mukherji,
Greetings. I am sure  ,though,unintentionally I hope ,from your  side, I get a feeling of getting demonized. 
I want a ' Pan Indian  and Indian language'.
1) My contention is Hindi does not fit the Bill. Sanskrit could have got its right full role of being 
Pan Indian , but for the arrogance of some people .( We have a local Telugu proverb which goes as  -- where ever I bath is Ganga & who ever, I covet is Rambha ie a celestial and Dev Indra's courtesan) . My agony is intensified  to note,rightly or wrongly, owing to failure of Gandhiji  in the selection of his linguist advisors we have been deprived of richness/pride/glory of having 'Ilm' ie 'Ken'  ie ' Gnan' of  our ancient  Sanskrit.
.2)You can consider me a proper Pan -Indian and a Hindi knowing secular chap! Yes, let all Indians share the same handicap of learning English and compete,rather than ,allowing a few the advantage of THEIR  'Madri Jaban/ Matru Bhasha'. Any way we Indians have been conditioned for the past 60 years or more ' To Share stupidity and poverty' and leave the goodies to the usual fortunate and blessed few ie Netas and their Betas + the Bad babus who do their bidding and so a compulsion to foist Hindi on non Hindi and Hindi speakers.
 3)And so, why not select at this belated stage a better tool ' Sanskrit' . The choice of Hybrid Hindi 
Will be in my opinion a sure shot remedy for perpetuating the misery of ignorance and hence backwardness.
Till Sanskrit is established, let the English( evil and Vile to the cow-beltHindi jingoists) would be a lesser evil with an added advantage of being understood by majority of our people ,as also majority of the world's people and is preferred tool for universal interactions in pursuit of excellence.
4)My feelings for Telugu or Tamil or Kannada or Malayalam or Oriya or Marathi or Gujarathi or Punjabi or Assamese or Kashmiri  to be a  
Pan-Indian language/medium  or same as those for Suddh or Misrit Hindi . That way Chinese are showing they are much more pragmatic than others in general and we Indians in particular ,by pursuing English-language with out weakening their ancient cultural moorings. We also can be equally pragmatic towards English and our own ancient Indian Culture .
Regards.
LtCol retd TTKishore

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Sanjay Chaturvedi
Date: Wednesday, January 30, 2013
Subject: Fwd: [IAC#RG] Hindi SE rashtravaad KA sambandh
To: indiaresists@lists.riseup.net


Dear Rina,

Your views are really very practical. I think some people only wish to challenge what makes the things smooth. Whereas people advocate for English be the common language, they do not hesitate to resist Hindii becoming the official common language, Like every other language Hindi speaking people naturally have more command on the language. but does it mean it belongs to them only?

With Regards

Sanjay Chaturvedi
9811074823
9873174823


On 30 January 2013 15:13, Rina Mukherji <rina.mukherji@gmail.com> wrote:
Sorry to intervene, Mr Triambakkishore. Though I do not endorse Hindi colonialism/imperialism, I find nothing wrong in having a single national language. The idea of having Hindi as the national language rose becauseof it being spoken in a majority of the provinces. It is true that in the north, all signs are put up in Hindi ( without a corresponding English one), but doing what the tamilians are doing-putting every sign up in Tamil-is hardly the solution.
 
The important thing is to get our history books and newspapers to be a little more mindful of representing India as a whole, and not be Delhi-centric.
 
Where the north Indians are concerned, you must pardon them their ignorance. Their idea of India is what they see in Bollywood films. For them, a Parsi is Muslim, the Oriyas and Assamese are all Bengali, and people from peninsular India- are all Madrasi. Even where Muslims are concerned, they feel surprised that Bengali Muslims, or the Gujarat Muslims do not use Urdu, but their respective regional languages!
You could attribute this to a very low literacy level, or a myopic vision; but that does not mean you should revile the learning of Hindi itself.
 
It is important , instead, to stress on the learning of each other's languages rather than foreign languages at the school level.
 
Rina
On Wed, Jan 30, 2013 at 3:54 AM, tadepalli triambakakishore <ltcolttkishore@gmail.com> wrote:
Dear All,
Greetings.
LtCol retd TTKishore

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: tadepalli triambakakishore
Date: Tuesday, January 29, 2013
Subject: Fwd: [IAC#RG] Hindi SE rashtravaad KA sambandh
To: prabhat jonathan <prabhatjon@gmail.com>


DearPrabhat Jonathan,
Pardon me for getting your name wrong.
While drafting the email ,I have forgotten to mention Bangla, Akhomese and eastern dialects ,Kashmiri,Dogri,Sindhi,Gujarati and MP's /UP's /Rajastan's Hindi dialects.
I couldn't help writing you some more.
How come even at this juncture people like Ashutosh JI are still labouring to assault rest of Bharat with their Shuddh Hindi. 
OR is it another attempt to drive away non -Hindi mother tongue persons by forces inimical to the on going transactions and interactions of IAC.
By the way, any middle school vernacular medium student can communicate in English with just 600 words vocabulary( including words like a,an, is, it, the, this, that,here,there,cat,rat,bat etc).
 1)What is Hindi ? Hindi as used by the protagonist is far cry from the lingo spoken in various parts of so called cow - belt.
Is' nt  the language a new cocktail of Urdu, Persian and Sanskrit? 

2)Gandhiji's pet project of a pan -Indian lingo had his so called linguistic stalwarts establishingHindi prachar Sabhas,and since it is blessed by Gandhiji, all Desh Bhakts Length and width of Bharat got carried away and went in to a over drive.It was forgotten that we People of Bharat are as different and diverse as a lily to jasmine to kevda to chrysanthemum or genda. Also we were not ruled by monarchs in the mould of Russians or Chinese or French . Moghuls andEnglish could' nt care, so long their courtiers spoke in the language they can understand.

3)English being a very simple language and THE RULER' S lingo,every impressionable person including Gandhiji,Nehru,Patel,Bose etc took to it being the only window of Hope and Thought as all aggregate Indian intellect was shoved to backburner by elite and supporters of the rulers,be they IMoghuls or English.(My Uncle ie elder brother of my father learnt Persian  along side Telugu and Sanskrit ,as Krishna District of AP then,was under Nizam's influence and my father studied English instead of Persian.)English was the means to upward mobility and to Developed Europe/America as English speaking men were calling the shots.

4)We people of Penensular India ie South India are indebted to Tamilians who stopped all jingoistic Hindi Vadi  in their tracks. My mother tongue Telugu is as evolved as as any other Earth' s language and so are Tamil/Malayalam /Kannada of Dravidian group of lingos. People are proud of their mother tongue and not Hindi(a hybrid to put mildly)

5).Where is the question of patriotism.We all know that Hindi was bound to aggravate the already existing backwardness as it was not in the same league as English for Scientific temperament,and had no appeal to seekers of excellence in all fields of human endeavor.

 I doubt whether Mr Ashutosh is not one of the cow- belt chaps for whom South of Vindhyas is MADRAS and all those in the region are MADRASIS who feels" Bhasha se Rashtr vaad ka sambandh hai". If so,my sympathies to his cerebral prowess and we get ready for more such assaults.
Please do me a favor of translating to Hindi for info of Mr Ashutosh and his ilk.( in retrospect WHAT THE HELL)

Sorry for the long conversation.
Regards.
LtCol retd TTKishore

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Ashu
Date: Tuesday, January 29, 2013
Subject: [IAC#RG]
To: indiaresists@lists.riseup.net


भाषा से राष्ट्रवाद का सम्बन्ध है .. 
मुझे इस बात से समस्या नहीं की किसी प्रान्त में हिंदी नहीं बोली जाती यदि हम चाहे तो मातृ भाषा सीख सकते हैं . मातृभाषा के निर्धारण का आधार पर लम्बी चर्चा हो सकती है . मगर गुलामी के प्रतिको को ढोते रहना कहाँ तक जायज है??
रही बात संसद की तो संसद में क्या होता है ये पूरा हिन्दुस्थान देखता है विश्व बैंक और यूरोप की दलाली पर चलने वाली संसद है ये .. आज तक अंग्रेजी कानून के अल्पविराम और पूर्ण विराम नहीं बदल पाए संसद के कर्णधार  तो संसद की भाषा कैसे बदलेंगे ...
यदि सिर्फ आधार बोले जाने का है तो कृपया मार्गदर्शन करे हिन्दुस्थान के कितने प्रतिशत लोग अंग्रेजी जानते हैं की इसे विचार सम्प्रेषण का माध्यम बना जाये।। इससे ज्यादा तो मराठी या तमिल जानने वाले होंगे ..

आशुतोष 

2013/1/28 Prabhat Jonathan <prabhatjon@gmail.com>
हाँ तो बंधु भाषा से भारतीयता का क्या संबंध है ? इस हिसाब से कई प्रांत जहां उन प्रांतो की भाषा बोली ओर लिखी जाती है वो तो भारत के ही नहीं हैं ? ऑर हिन्दी ऑर अँग्रेजी दोनों ही संसद की भाषा है भाई मेरे तो सभी को हक़ है किसी भी भाषा मे लिखने के लिए ऑर कोई ऑर नहीं मेरे से ही बात करें

2013/1/25 Ashu <ashu7oct@gmail.com>
सब इंडियन हैं या कोई भारतीय भी है यहाँ॥कई दिन से प्रयास कर रहा हूँ कोई हमारी मातृभाषा मे लिखे और उससे ज्ञानार्जन हो मगर यहाँ तो मैकाले की गंगोत्री दिख रही है ॥ 

जय श्री राम 




--

Yesterday is gone. Tomorrow has not yet come. We have only today. Let us begin.

Prabhat Jonathan
C-DAC
New Delhi

Post: "indiaresists@lists.riseup.net"
Exit: "indiaresists-unsubscribe@lists.riseup.net"
Quit: "https://lists.riseup.net/www/signoff/indiaresists"
Help: https://help.riseup.net/en/list-user
WWW : http://indiaagainstcorruption.net.in




--
LTCOL(retd) T T KISHORE
FLAT NO-134, SECTOR-A,
AWHO COLONY, SIKH ROAD,
GAUTAM ENCLAVE,
SECUNDERABAD-09
Res-040-27840415
Cell-9912594602



--
LTCOL(retd) T T KISHORE
FLAT NO-134, SECTOR-A,
AWHO COLONY, SIKH ROAD,
GAUTAM ENCLAVE,
SECUNDERABAD-09
Res-040-27840415
Cell-9912594602

Post: "indiaresists@lists.riseup.net"
Exit: "indiaresists-unsubscribe@lists.riseup.net"
Quit: "https://lists.riseup.net/www/signoff/indiaresists"
Help: https://help.riseup.net/en/list-user
WWW : http://indiaagainstcorruption.net.in


Post: "indiaresists@lists.riseup.net"
Exit: "indiaresists-unsubscribe@lists.riseup.net"
Quit: "https://lists.riseup.net/www/signoff/indiaresists"
Help: https://help.riseup.net/en/list-user
WWW : http://indiaagainstcorruption.net.in




--
LTCOL(retd) T T KISHORE
FLAT NO-134, SECTOR-A,
AWHO COLONY, SIKH ROAD,
GAUTAM ENCLAVE,
SECUNDERABAD-09
Res-040-27840415
Cell-9912594602

No comments:

Post a Comment