Re: [HumJanenge] Re: Missing requests in the CIC

1. that sic decision in guru ramdas hospital trust was made in my case
(order is enclosed). They have already moved HC (I am also the
respondent in the matter).
2. I did not ask sgpc anything about any religious matter. I simply
asked about this same trust from CPIO.
3. Now I will make some more research in the matter and also let an
affected party take up the case.
regards

On 8/2/12, Sarbajit Roy <sroy.mb@gmail.com> wrote:
> I am unable to find anywhere on the internet (ie. section 4
> disclosure) who the SGPC's PIO(s) is.
> In fact sometime in June 2012, Mr. Makkar again said SGPC would be
> approaching High Court against SIC-Punjab's decision in Guru Ramdas
> Hospital Trust case.
> http://punjabnewslinenetwork.com/index.php/religion-community/3300-why-should-sgpc-not-come-under-right-to-information-act
>
> It seems there is complete confusion if SGPC is a Central or State P/A.
>
> BTW, if SGPC gave info to appellant in MLS's order does not mean they
> have appointed CPIO. In one of my own matters (Delhi DISCOMs) they
> gave me information but thereafter went to Court and obtained stay
> (still pending).
>
> So I would suggest that you research this matter properly before
> pursuing it before the competent forum. In any case it would be better
> that the affected section of society (ie. Sikhs) pursue this case
> rather than habitual RTI activists who interfere after reading about
> it in the newspapers.
>
> PS: So I am right in assuming that you simply sent your RTI by post
> addressed to CPIO/SGPC ??
>
> Sarbajit
>
> On 8/2/12, Sandeep gupta <drsandgupta@gmail.com> wrote:
>> Mr. Makkar is lying when he says that SGPC has not appointed any CPIOs
>> The SGPC has appointed CPIO on CIC's order of 28 March 2011 and has
>> also provided the demanded information
>> I did not write the name of CPIO on the application. I simply wrote CPIO,
>> SGPC
>> Keeping in view the above background I feel that I have not made any
>> false statement
>> to CIC
>>
>>
>> On 8/2/12, sarbajit roy <sroy.mb@gmail.com> wrote:
>>> Dear Sandeep
>>>
>>> 1) Is Mr. Makkar lying when he says that SGPC has not appointed any
>>> CPIOs ?
>>>
>>> 2) What is the action, if any, the SGPC has taken on CIC's order of
>>> 28 March 2011 in "Kuldeep Singh Khaira" where IC(MLS) has found /
>>> declared SGPC to be a P/A ?
>>>
>>> 3) How did you FILE your RTI if SGPC has not appointed any PIOs ? In
>>> fact IC(MLS) gave SGPC Amritsar 6 weeks time to do so, ie by 13 May
>>> 2011. Your RTI request was allegedly filed on 26 May 2011. So can you
>>> name the CPIO you filed with ?
>>>
>>> 4) In background of point 3 above , Have you given a false statement
>>> to CIC that you have FILED your RTI request to CPIO of SGPC ?
>>>
>>> Please clarify specifically and dont confuse these points with other
>>> issues (which we can discuss separately).
>>>
>>> THE ISSUE HERE IS OF ORDERS OF CIC (to appoint CPIO + FAA) NOT BEING
>>> COMPLIED WITH.
>>>
>>> Sarbajit
>>>
>


--
Dr. Sandeep Kumar Gupta
1722, Sector 14, Hisar-125001, INDIA
Phone: 91-99929-31181