Re: [IAC#RG] Bizarre anti-nationalism of Vice President Sh.VenkaiahNaidu?

Dear Mr. Architect

This is a serious non-political discussion mailing list for intellectuals of India Against Corruption, and you are insulting our membership by describing them as 'Pakis'.

If you are correct then you, and the Vice President, are insufficiently informed about the National Anthem.

Official orders and instructions of the Govt of India (on website of MHA) clearly indicate that it is the National Anthem, ie. JanGanMan, which is for respectful salutation of the motherland when acheieved by mass singing.

These official orders also indicate about the compulsory playing of the National Anthem  with the "National Salute" ie.the Command "Rashtriya  Salute – Salami Shastr".

Dr. Roy is correct that the Vande Mataram is neither the National Anthem nor the National Song and there are no orders of Govt of India to regulate the compulsory playing/singing of Vande Mataram and it's singing cannot be forced on the citizens.

So the "problem" many patriotic Indians have with the compulsory singing / utterance of the Vande Mataram is that it implies "bowing" to some mythical Mother Goddess and thereby disrespecting that one and only protector and unifying power of India who is praised in our National Anthem.

RP Dalvi

On Sun, Dec 10, 2017 at 11:03 PM, Sudhir Srinivasan <arsudhirkumar@gmail.com> wrote:

Dear Paki's,

 

Vice President Shri.Venkaiah Naidu – Never said Stop / not to singing national Anthem

VP – only questioned Paki lovers, what problem Congress / BSP / Muslims have in saying Vande Mataram

VP – said Vande Mataram meaning – saluting the motherland.

 

Congress and Dr Zakir Hussain followers with low IQ have totally missed the point.

 

Sent from Mail for Windows 10

 

From: Dr Sarman Singh
Sent: Sunday 10 December 2017 5:21 pm
To: MRCI - Ramesh Patil
Cc: indiaresists@lists.riseup.net
Subject: Re: [IAC#RG] Bizarre anti-nationalism of Vice President Sh.VenkaiahNaidu?

 

The discussion is very intellectual one. But for my friends these days even pointing out the mistakes or dirty mindset of BJP is antinational acts and all of the government employees are afraid of to say anything about their misdeeds. So to survive in these days of dictatorship, better to say only Jai ho modi, even if you do feel like from your heart.