[HumJanenge] Re: IRDS Seminar , RTI & Misinformation to Citizenry

To:
The Group Owner / Moderator
HUMJANENGE@GOOGLEGROUPS

28-Oct-2010

Dear Sirs,

I thank you for the invitation extended to me to join your group. My
attention has been drawn to the email purporting to be from me and
which was posted to this list a few days back.

I request you to kindly delete the said email as it is personal (and
copyrighted) to the RTI_India (yahoogroup) where I am the list owner.
I would also request you to kindly send me the original copy of the
email as received by you (with full headers) to enable me to identify
the sender of the message so that I can expel him from the RTI_India
group for Yahoo ToS violations.

I also take strong exception to being misidentified with / to the
email ID "humjanenge.owner@gmail.com". This is
a false and deceptive practice and I request you (whoever you are) to
stop such shady practices immediately.

I also wish to state for the record that despite being member of
HumJanenge (yahoo) forum many years, the
moderators there (for reasons best known to them) do not allow me to
post to that list. I therefore have no desire to be associated with
Humjanenge's 'haramis' in any of its forms and avatars and I request
you to kindly unsubscribe me from this group / list immediately.

Yours faithfully

Sarbajit Roy

On Oct 26, 11:34 pm, sarbajitr <humjanenge.ow...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Dear Madam,
>
> The Moderator of this group is not available to communicate with you at the
> present time due to some preoccupations.
>
> In my capacity as list owner, I am informing you that we have stringent
> rules for posting to this group. CrossPosting the same message to multiple
> RTI groups is strongly discouraged by popular demand (we had a vote on
> this).
>
> Furthermore, after reading your post, I can safely say that you are a fool
> and we do not tolerate fools and/or their foolishness on this group (unless
> it is clearly marked as such).
>
> Sarbajit
>
> --- In rti_in...@yahoogroups.com <rti_india%40yahoogroups.com>, Babita Singh<babitasinghindia@...> wrote:
>
> > IRDS Seminar , RTI & Misinformation to Citizenry
> > Â
> >http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o6lsqkoqAk8&feature=mfu_in_order
> > Â
> > Institute for Research and Documentation in Social Sciences (IRDS) Lucknow
>
> Seminar is Misinforming Citizenry on Right to Information ( RTI ) Act 2005> Â
> > Friends,
> > Â
> > I present before you a very interesting case of a Seminar dated 07-02-2010
>
> , organized by the  Institute for Research and Documentation in Social
> Sciences (IRDS) by  a Non-governmental organization ( NGO ) based in
> Lucknow . The website of this NGO reads “Institute for Research and
> Documentation in Social Sciences (IRDS), a Non government Organization, was
> founded by some like-minded and public-spirited people in the year 1996. It
> is registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 and has been
> granted permission under the FCR Act to accept foreign
> donations/contributions. The Organization has also been exempted under
> section 80 G of the IT Act. It is working in various fields of Social
> services with the aim of making selfless, positive and substantial
> contribution to the overall development of the Nation and its people.â€> Â
> > In this Seminar Experts were Mis-educating the citizenry on RTI act 2005.
>
> The experts opined   “Second Appeal can be made under section 18 of RTI
> act 2005†and that “Second appeals are made under section 19(2) of the
> RTI act 2005 †.> Â
> > A news Video on you-tube suggests that all those present in the seminar
>
> subscribed to this totally wrong and baseless spread of information about
> the complaints and appeals that are to be made under RTI act 2005 . This
> also projects the ignorance level about the RTI act 2005 even in year 2010
> in NGOs and experts who organized and attended this seminar on RTI .> Â
> > Anyone who does not know the basic difference between the complaints of
>
> section 18 and second appeals of section 19(3) , should not be allowed to
> mis-educate others on RTI in seminars . NGOs should look into it as their
> office-bearers should concentrate on substance delivered  in seminars
> rather than treating seminars and NGOs  as a holy cow whom they milk
> whenever they want.
>
> > Â
> > This video ( link given ) should immediately be removed from the you-tube
> site.
> > Â
> >http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o6lsqkoqAk8&feature=mfu_in_order
> > Â
> > Â
> > Â
> > Â